Your basket

Join The FSA

Police chief criticises "invasive, disproportionate" tactics at South Wales derby

The North Wales police and crime commissioner Arfon Jones has criticised the use of facial recognition cameras on supporters at this weekend’s Cardiff City v Swansea City fixture, claiming that football fans are being unfairly targeted by South Wales Police. 

Mr Jones, a 30-year veteran of the force who was elected to his position in 2016, accused South Wales Police of going on a “fishing expedition” with fans of the two clubs, claiming that they were being targeted “in a way that supporters of other sports are not”.

He also raised concerns as to the effectiveness of the technology, particular with black and asian fans.

“When facial recognition technology was first used in the Champions League final at the Millennium Stadium there were several hundred, if not thousands, of false positives, so there have to be concerns about its accuracy.

“There have also been concerns [about its effectiveness], especially so with members of the BAME community, and I don’t know if these have been satisfactorily addressed.”

The police chief joins fans of both clubs, who have previously spoken out against the use of facial recognition cameras at the sides’ previous meeting at the Liberty Stadium in October.

Despite the previous outcry, police will persist with its use again this weekend.

Vince Alm from the Cardiff City Supporters’ Club (an FSA affiliate) said “It’s unbelievable that police are targeting us with facial recognition surveillance again. Fans coming out for a local football match, including hundreds of families and children, will be treated like they’re in a police line-up and have their faces scanned without their consent.”

The use of the technology by South Wales police is in addition to the ‘bubble match’ travel restrictions imposed on fans.

One Swansea fan faces an ‘absurd 200 mile round trip’ – being forced to travel all the way from Cardiff to Swansea to catch a coach to attend the match, and then being taken back to Swansea afterwards – to a game being played around a mile from his home.

Facial recognition software has also attracted criticism outside football, with civil liberties campaign group Big Brother Watch calling for an immediate ban of its use in all contexts throughout the UK.

Related Articles

South Wales Police suffer facial recognition setback

The use of live facial recognition technology by South Wales Police is unlawful, according to a new ruling from the Court of Appeal which could have significant implications for football fans.

Sustain The Game: “No silver bullet” says Pompey chief exec

On Friday we launched our Sustain The Game! campaign and since then it has been endorsed by supporters and high-profile figures across the game – here Portsmouth chief executive Mark Catlin argues that regulation must be strengthened but there are no easy answers or “one size fits all” solutions…

A letter to supporters from EFL chief executive David Baldwin

On Friday the chief executive of the EFL, David Baldwin, wrote an open letter to football fans ahead of the weekend’s test events which saw fans return to live football for the first time across the three divisions since March…

Leeds mural celebrates anti-racism work of “The Chief”

Leeds United fans have unveiled a new mural of one of their cult heroes to celebrate diversity in the city in a project funded by the Fans for Diversity campaign.

Funding partners

  • The Football Association
  • Premier Leage Fans Fund


  • Gamble Aware
  • Co-operatives UK
  • FSE
  • Kick It Out
  • Level Playing Field
  • Living Wage Foundation
  • Pledgeball
  • SD Europe