Your basket

Join The FSA

Sheffield derby policing: what fans said

This is a story from the FSF archive – the FSF and SD merged to become the FSA in 2019.

Last week we surveyed more than 1,000 Sheffield Wednesday and Sheffield United fans to get their thoughts on policing operation before and after the Steel City derby.

Some of the headline figures have already been reported, you can see those here, and now we can release the results of that consultation in more detail. Take a look below…

FSF Sheffield derby consultation

  • 1012 respondents from Thursday 7th March to Sunday 10th March 2019.


  • 40.7% said policing was worse than previous derbies (51.1% about the same)
  • Asked to give a score out of 10, with 1 being very poor and 10 being excellent, the pre-match operation was rated on average as 4.2 from all respondents.


  • 72.6% said it was worse than previously (24.3% about the same)
  • Asked to give a score out of 10, with 1 being very poor and 10 being excellent, the post-match operation was rated on average as 1.9
  • 70.7% describe the management of the exit from the stadium as very poor, a further 14.8% described it as poor. Just 4.3% described it as good or very good
  • Only 11 of 929 fans (1.2%) described police instructions post-match as clear, audible and helpful.

South Yorkshire Police

  • 79.5% describe SYP as ‘worse than the average’ when compared with forces around the country (13% say they’re roughly the same)
  • Only 38.5% would describe SYP’s general policing at other home matches as adequate, and 15.2% saying it was good or very good.

Supporter engagement
When asked what they should do to improve their matchday policing, the most popular responses were:

  • Have more proactive interactions with fans: 66.7%
  • Include supporters in pre-match planning/discussions: 65.1%
  • Improve pre-match communications/messages: 53.3%
  • Improve their engagement with fans through social media: 37.3%

What fans said

We asked supporters for their general feedback on the policing operation, here is just a small selection of the many comments left:

Treating the 99% of good natured football fans as hooligans creates an atmosphere of hostility which is not seen in any other sport or public event

Police are intimidating and unapproachable, they yell instructions and were hitting individual who did not follow them immediately even if unable to (I.e if the path was blocked)

Lost control. Had no idea what they were doing. Swinging batons at anyone they pleased

Atrocious, didn’t care and thought hitting people with batons when they tried to move in the crush of people was a good idea. Legalised assault on many occasions and absolutely unneccesary

Leppings lane policing was irresponsible, bottlenecking fans on the road at the same time caused multiple fights and distress to regular fans

I don’t understand why both sets of fans were allowed out of the ground at the same time. The road layout doesn’t change, so I don’t understand why they can’t plan an exit strategy well before a match. They just allow things to happen and try to react.

The FSF has approached South Yorkshire Police for a response to our survey’s findings, at the time of publication they have yet to respond.

Thanks to PA Images for the image used in this blog.

Related Articles

New policing bill: Criminalising traditional fan behaviour?

There’s been a lot of talk recently about the controversial Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill currently making its way through Parliament – here FSA caseworker Amanda Jacks discusses its potential impact on match-going fans…

New Policing Bill: FSA submits evidence to Parliament

The Joint Committee on Human Rights is scrutinising the controversial Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill, which was introduced into Parliament in March earlier this year.

Petition calls for halt to new Policing Bill

Almost 60,000 people have signed a petition started by human rights group Liberty to stop the controversial Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill becoming law.

Fan group in focus: Sheffield Wednesday Women’s Supporters Group

Sheffield Wednesday Women’s Supporters Group formed in April 2023 and hit the headlines with some fantastic fundraising work earlier this season in response to an incident at Hillsborough. In one of our Fan Group In Focus features they explain more…

Funding partners

  • The Football Association
  • Premier Leage Fans Fund


  • Gamble Aware
  • Co-operatives UK
  • FSE
  • Kick It Out
  • Level Playing Field
  • Living Wage Foundation
  • Pledgeball